In February 1963, the adjoining building located at 475 Vermont street was purchased. The parishioners, through their efforts and concern, loaned the Church the funds for the purchase. The church repaid each member their initial loan. Building plans to renovate and decorate with new pews began. Two members donated $200.00 each, out their small savings, so that the renovation contract could be consummated. The work on the church was completed by April, with one hundred twenty-five members on roll, and seating capacity for150 persons. Renovations continued as God blessed the efforts of Pastor Underwood and the Grace Baptist Church Family.

On July 17, the second mile of our work for our Lord and Master began and the first four Deacons were ordained. They were the late Major Cunningham, Thomas Perkins, Harold Mattocks and William Jordan. Trustees were appointed at a later date. Choirs and Auxiliaries were formed and they grew in numbers.

The church proceeded to become involved in education, housing, a freedom school and the East New York Civil Rights Group. Many community groups and Associations were organized on the church premises.